10 Must-Know Lead Scoring Best Practices to Win Your Leads in 2022

Are you satisfied with your lead scoring? If the answer is “no” or “maybe”, keep reading.

This post will look at the 10 best lead scoring practices for driving better results. You’ll also discover the single most common mistake that jeopardizes your lead scoring strategy.

Let’s dive in!

Sidenote: If you are brand new to lead scoring, make sure first to read our post on what lead scoring is and how to use it in your business.

10 Must-Know Lead Scoring Best Practices

  1. Start small, scale as you go
  2. Assign a lead scoring threshold
  3. Use negative points
  4. Talk to your customers
  5. Integrate your CRM and marketing automation with lead scoring
  6. Customize your model based on high-value pages
  7. Set up a point decay rate
  8. Repetitive behavior
  9. Refine your lead scoring strategy regularly
  10. Create multiple lead scoring systems for different products

1. Start small, scale as you go

Most marketers make the mistake of trying to make their first implementation perfect. They bite more than they can chew.

If you haven’t used lead scoring before or are just launching a new lead scoring process now, there is no point in overwhelming yourself.

Imagine creating the perfect system, carefully preparing dozens of scores, and then, after 5 months of hard work, you find out your lead scoring fundamentally doesn’t work. You have to start from scratch.

So… You might be wondering if you should care about the strategy at all.

Yes, you should. The best way to go about it is to put together the essential parts in place and create a simple lead scoring flow.

For instance, your starting strategy may look like the flow below. The scoring is calculated based on the 3 most critical actions users perform in the app: “Signed Up’, “Task Created”, and “Project Created.” 

You can adapt a similar method for your product and use the most important aha moments to score leads and users.

Regardless of whether you run a B2B SaaS app, a B2C service, or some other type of digital business, avoid starting with a complex lead scoring process. 

Here’s what you should do instead:

  1. Choose the 3 to 5 most important triggers to score. If you are a SaaS product, you can score app actions; if you are a marketing agency, you can score your lead nurturing form submissions and your demo bookings, and so on.
  2. Keep scores simple. For instance, increase each positive action by 5 points. No need to go crazy on the numericals at this point. 
  3. Launch and see if this flow helps you qualify leads or if it needs adjustment.

After a while, you can start building upon that foundation as you collect more feedback, understand your audience better, and learn more about the best practices of scoring leads (kudos on doing so right now!) 

2. Assign a lead scoring threshold

Setting the right lead scoring threshold will maximize your sales potential. A threshold is a point value where a lead is considered sales-ready or qualified and should be passed on to your sales team for further outreach. 

Lead scoring best practice - set a leadscoring treshold diagram

Now it’s essential to get the threshold value right. Fail do to so, and either of these could help:

  1. If your threshold is too low – leads won’t be sales-ready, yet you’ll be sending them to your sales reps, which will lead to a low number of closed deals, and an increase in customer acquisition costs as your salespeople spend time on bad leads.
  2. If your threshold is too high – you risk losing sales-ready leads to your competitors.

We are not going to lie. It’s hard to figure out what the ideal lead scoring threshold is. It will take a lot of data, time, and feedback from your sales team to nail it down. Even then, your lead scoring will never be perfect. 

Pro tip: The easiest way to approach this is to talk directly to your sales reps. They’ll know exactly when a lead is ready to be converted and should be above the threshold. Good sales and marketing alignment is the key in this exercise. 

But what’s even worse is not setting a threshold at all. That means you are simply collecting lead-scoring data for the sake of collecting it and not acting on it. The lead scoring threshold gives you the green light to act.

That’s why you should make sure to decide and set up a threshold from day one. 

Encharge makes this super easy with segments. Use the field condition to build a segment of all people who reach a specific lead score. For example, all people with a lead score of more than 20:

Encharge high lead score segment

Then, you can send your leads to CRM and even assign a follow-up task to your sales reps as soon as your leads reach the threshold. To do that, you can use the Entered Segment trigger step to automate sales tasks in your CRM. 

In the example flow below, a new deal is created in HubSpot, and a task to follow up with the lead is assigned to the sales rep.

Encharge high lead score flow example

3. Use negative points

Most people focus only on the positive actions a lead performs. They increase the score for every email open, opt-in, page visit, reply, etc.

But what about the negative actions?

If you are like most marketers, you don’t pay too much attention to negative scoring. You might be totally ignoring it. But that can completely mess up your lead scoring system and drive poor results.

If a lead keeps opening emails but also visits your careers page, they might not be a sales opportunity at all.

If you don’t account for the negative scoring, you will get a lead with a high score, and you’ll be wondering, “Why are they not replying to emails?” When in fact, the poor guy (or a gal) is simply interested in applying for a job at your company.

An easy way to prevent this is to add negative scores to “punish” bad behavior such as:

  • Canceling appointments.
  • Unsubscribing from your email list.
  • Visiting the careers page.
  • Has a free email address.
  • Is a competitor.

You can see an example of that below.

Negative lead scoring in Encharge

4. Talk to your customers

Staying in the loop with your team is essential, but so is talking to customers.

You never really know what works in marketing — you can only guess.  One way to turn guessing into “knowing” is by testing.

For instance, you can A/B test different variations of your messaging and find out which one is better.

Yet, testing requires a lot of data and time, and even then will only give you quantitative data.

The best and easiest way to find out how to close your leads is to ask your customers directly. You can create forms, send them feedback emails, or schedule a phone call with them.

Feedback email example from Airbnb
Source: Esputnik

Doing so will help you tremendously as you start to understand your leads’John is motivations, challenges, and timeframes. 

5. Integrate your CRM and marketing automation with lead scoring

Want an effective lead scoring system?

You need your CRM and your marketing automation tool tightly connected and working together, hand-by-hand. 


How does this work exactly?

Marketing automation does all the lead scoring in the background and automates customer journeys for you.

Flow in Encharge

Everything you see above is possible only because of marketing automation. If it weren’t in place, you would have to do everything manually. In this example, it would mean:

  • Checking everyone’s score
  • Finding high-score leads 
  • Writing personalized emails
  • Sending the emails

You would have to do everything yourself, email by email. That would be impossible to do. 

Secondly, there is your CRM – customer relationship management. This is your single source of truth for your sales reps. Deals, follow-ups, and all sales-related tasks live in your CRM.

Further reading:  What is the Difference Between CRM and Marketing Automation?

If you want the best results, you must connect both of these systems together. 

Doing this with Encharge is a breeze. You can choose your favorite CRM like HubSpot or Salesforce and integrate it with Encharge.

Encharge and HubSpot integraton

It’s fast, easy, and powerful.

6. Customize your model based on high-value pages

When it comes to lead scoring, not all activities are equal. The same applies to your web pages on your website. 

For instance, let’s say you are measuring time on site. And there are two leads, let’s call them Mark and John. 

Mark is visiting your “About Us” page, and his time on site is 3 minutes. Then, there is John, looking at your Pricing, but he stays there only for 2 minutes.

Which of these actions do you find more valuable?

The second one, for sure. Yet if you don’t score high-value pages and actions differently, your score would be inaccurate. You’d be giving a lot more points to Mark instead of John, that has a much higher potential for turning into a customer.

And this is why your lead scoring model must account for these things.

To achieve this in Encharge:

  1. Install the website tracking code in your website’s <head> section. This is needed to track page visits.
  2. Create a flow using the Page Visited trigger
Lead scoring based on page visits in Encharge

Mostly it’s just details like these that really make the difference. So be sure to set it up in your lead scoring system and award high-value behavior.

7. Set up a point decay rate

Imagine you have a hot lead.

They open every email, download content, visit blog posts, and doeverything that a well-qualified lead does.

Lead scoring diagram

But after a while, all of that stops. Maybe it’s because a lead does not need your product anymore or has signed up for a competitor. Either way, they no longer engage with your company the way they used to.

If you fail to set up a point decay rate, their score will stay the same over time.

That means your leads might not be interested or be already using competitors’ products, yet you still perceive them as hot leads.

So what is point decay, and how to set it up?

Point decay is decreasing lead points after some time of no activity. For instance, you can set it up like this:

  • 30 days of no action – 15 points subtracted
  • 60 days of no action – 30 points subtracted 
  • 90 days of no action – 50 points subtracted 

Doing so will allow you to eliminate leads that are no longer interested.

It will clean your list and remove leads that would never turn into customers. The length of the point decay should be based on the length of your sales cycle. 

Experiment with it, talk to your team and make sure to set it properly.

To set a point decay rate in Encharge, create segments with the Last Activity field. For example:

Inactive segment in Encharge

Then, you simply use the Entered Segment trigger with the Lead Score step:

Lead scoring flow based on inactivity in Encharge

8. Repetitive behavior

Most businesses score leads based on a specific action. For instance, if a lead opens an email, it gets 3 points; if it visits your website, it gets 1 point.

While there is nothing wrong with that, you must score repeated actions, too.

A lead visiting a pricing page 5 times is a lot more engaged than a lead that does it only once. Yet, you give no additional points for repetitive behavior, and your lead scoring system will get skewed.

That’s why you must account for that and increase the score with repeated actions. It’s the only way to maximize score accuracy and get the desired results.

In Encharge, most triggers get fired every time the action is performed. So, for instance, in the example below, the lead will receive 2 points every time they click on the specific email:

Email activity lead scoring flow

9. Refine your lead scoring strategy regularly

Many marketers like the idea of “Set it and forget it.” 

But if you approach your lead scoring this way, you will most likely experience a big downfall.

Your business is changing all the time, and what might have worked in the past might not work now. 

Some patterns are also a reason to revisit your lead scoring:

Do you see a drop in the number of conversions or sales? 

Maybe you’re getting many qualified leads but no conversions – you have a low threshold.

Either way, it signalizes that you should change up a few things.

Even if everything works just fine, there is always a way to make things better. We suggest having a meeting with your marketing and sales team at least once a quarter to revisit your strategy together.

Doing so can lead to a massive increase in closed deals for your business.

That isn’t true for only lead scoring, though.

When sales and marketing teams are in sync, companies become 67% better at closing deals.

Source: Marketo

You should be revisiting all your marketing strategies, perfecting your campaigns, and delivering better results over time.

10. Create multiple lead scoring systems for different products

If your company has several product lines or services, it is best to create a separate lead scoring model for every product. This should be a no-brainer, yet many companies use a generic model for all products.

A great example of a multi-product company is Google.

They sell their Google Pixel phone, Google Workspace apps, and PPC ads. Do you think using one lead scoring model for all of these products is a good idea?

Google products
Source: Quartz

Of course not. It’s nonsense. Leads buying these products are totally different. 

Yet if you use a generic lead scoring system for all of them, you are throwing all these different leads into one basket, which is far from optimal. 

11. BONUS: Don’t score every email open

Email opens can be a great indicator of a lead’s interest.

However, if you are scoring every email open, you might inflate your score and skew your system.

Suppose you’re sending emails every day. There are two leads, one is checking your pricing page, and the other is just opening your emails. If we ask you which of these leads is more valuable, your answer is probably the first one.

But the score could say the opposite.

And that’s why it’s much better to look at the click rates, conversions from emails, and other more valuable metrics than just email open.

That’s why only 11.5% of marketers are only scoring based on conversions from emails — the rest are scoring based on a combination of opens, clicks, and conversions. (Source).

Ready to perfect your lead scoring strategy with these best practices?

Lead scoring is an excellent way to maximize your sales potential.

Unfortunately, few businesses use lead scoring to its full power. 

In this post, we’ve armed you with the knowledge to apply the 11 best lead scoring practices in your marketing automation strategy for 2022. 

Or sign up for a 14-day free Encharge trial and start scoring your leads today.

4.8/5 from 228 reviews
4.9/5 from 158 reviews
4.9/5 from 155 reviews
4.91/5 from 154 reviews

Meet your new marketing automation platform

Customer messaging tools don’t automate workflows outside your product and marketing automation tools are bad at behavior emails. Encharge is the best of both worlds — a marketing automation platform built specifically for startups and digital businesses.

“Encharge helped us visually redesign our onboarding flow resulting in a 10% increase in our trial activation rate."

camille-photo
Camille Richon
Founder Payfacile
See why Encharge is different
Use Cases
Marketing automation
Create user journeys that convert, onboard, and retain customers.
Lead nurturing
Nurture email leads into trial users and customers.
User onboarding
Boost product activation and guide your users to value faster
Trial conversion
Smart marketing automation and behavior-based emails to double your trial conversion.
Success Stories
Landbot automates the onboarding for 80,000+ users while saving 320 hours/month
Samdock reduced the cost and time spent on acquiring a new customer by 77% with Encharge
Aito reduced the time for implementing behavior-based emails from hours to minutes
laptop
SaaS
Convert, onboard, and retain more customers. Grow your MRR with marketing automation for SaaS.
meeting
Agencies
Build advanced marketing automation flows for your clients and grow your agency faster than ever before.
document-2
Content creators
Bring your subscribers in Encharge and nurture them into customers with automated email sequences.
opening-times
Subscription businesses
Create targeted messages and automation flows for recurring-revenue businesses.
automated-logistics
Productized services
Automate your services and focus on the important parts of your business.
Flow builder
Create remarkable user journeys with a robust and easy to use visual flow builder.
Broadcasts
Send targeted one-off newsletters to your whole audience or a segment of people.
Behavior emails
Send targeted emails when people do or don’t do something in your app.
User segments
Create user segments with the market’s leading segmentation for SaaS.
User profiles
See the people behind the actions and access the full view of your customer data.
Email personalization
Get your users to act with highly-personalized emails.
Email editor
Design beautiful mobile-ready emails without any HTML skills.
A/B tests
Drive email engagement with A/B tests for your Broadcasts and your Flows.
Lead scoring
Identify interested users and best-fit customers and proactively reach out to them.
Website tracking
Track page visits and form submissions on your website in real-time.
verified
Free email verification
Free email verification for all your contacts in Encharge, on all plans.
Transactional emails
Send emails like password reset, payment receipt, and single sign-on link from your app.
Facebook Logo
Facebook
HubSpot Logo
HubSpot
Calendly Logo
Calendly
Typeform Logo
Typeform
Slack Logo
Slack
Intercom Logo
Intercom
Mailchimp Logo
Mailchimp
Salesforce Logo
Salesforce
Zapier Logo
Zapier
Pabbly Logo
Pabbly
Integrately Logo
Integrately
Stripe Logo
Stripe
Chargebee Logo
Chargebee
Chargify Logo
Chargify
Recurly Logo
Recurly
Paddle Logo
Paddle
Twilio Logo
Twilio SMS
Webhooks Logo
Webhooks
Segment Logo
Segment
API Logo
API
Google Analytics Logo
Google Analytics
SyncSpider logo
SyncSpider
KonnectzIT logo
KonnectzIT
ThriveCart Logo
ThriveCart
+38
More
Blog
The resource for startups who want to grow their revenue with marketing automation.
logo-facebook
Facebook Group
A community for all things Encharge-related.
Knowledge base
Learn how to use Encharge.
window-dev
Developer Docs
Tools for developers.
thumb-up
Feature Requests
Request new product features.
Product Updates
Latest Encharge updates and news.
Affiliate Program
Earn up to 30% recurring commission when you refer customers to Encharge.
b-check
Encharge Experts
Get help from trusted Encharge consultants and service providers.
books
Resource Library
Get access to all of our eBooks, webinars, blueprints, cheatsheets, and more.
artificial-brain
Generate Subject Lines with AI
Create unique subject lines with the only free AI email subject line generator based on GPT3.
logo-slack
Slack community
Talk to the Encharge team in real-time.